Journal of Business and Management
ISSN: 1535-668X
 
| Current Issue | All Issues unlock


Paper Review Decision Process

Your paper will be judged according to the following criteria:
(1) Novelty of problem
(2) Uniqueness of perspective
(3) Innovativeness of model
(4) Completeness of literature review
(5) Appropriateness of research method
(6) Theoretical contribution
(7) Readability of paper

  Second Reviewer's Decision
Conclusion Accept Minor Revisions Major Revisions Reject
First Reviewer's Decision Accept Accepted for Publication Send back for Revision, then Accept Send back for Revision, then Reexamine *
Minor Revisions Send back for Revision, then Accept Send back for Revision, then Accept Send back for Revision, then Reexamine *
Major Revisions Send back for Revision, then Reexamine Send back for Revision, then Reexamine Send back for Revision, then Reexamine Reject
Reject * * Reject Reject

* In this case, the editor in chief or executive editor will make a decision (i.e., reject, seek the third reviewer's opinion, or ask for major revisions) by evaluating the scores and commands from the two reviewers.

 

CC BY-NC 4.0  Content on the JBM by the ICEB is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 (CC BY-NC 4.0) International license
CCU-COM

ICEB

COPYRIGHT BY Journal of Business and Management
Authorized by International Consotium for Electronic Business, San Luis Obispo, CA, USA
Published by College of Management, National Chung Cheng University, Chiayi, Taiwan
Tel:+886-9-16733800 | E-mail: jbm.homeoffice@gmail.com